In Which We End Up Yelling At Children *Shame*

There is peril in blogging angry.

For one thing, I rarely look back and read over what I've read in an angry mood and think: "Yes, indeed, I am proud of how I am representing myself there, make copies and send one to the Queen." More likely I cringe and get an itchy "Delete Post" finger. (This is the main reason why most of my diaries, those still in existence anyway, have large sections of their pages stapled together - I loathe the idea of destroying my own records but I also don't want to have them so readily available for reading. The staple is sort of symbolic, obviously, as I have a staple remover as well as the stapler itself, but it does the trick.)

I've yapped at length about my troubled relationship with East Harlem so let's suffice with this recap for first timers: I moved to the neighborhood in October of 2002 and have lived in two apartments since. I live in East Harlem proper, not a pretty little place on 97th street, and since living here, I have had lots of good experiences but also lots of shitty ones - usually of the racial/gentrification anger persuasion and entirely without provocation (unless you consider being white provocation, which, whatever, you may. I don't know your life.)

A couple of blogs have popped up recently touting the beauties of Spanish Harlem, quoting, as I once did, the abundance of real culture, the terrific family neighborhood feel, the amazing variety of excellent street food and the general lack of astronomical rents that make the rest of Manhattan sort of obnoxious for those of us either too poor or too sensible to spend $3,000/month on a walk-in closet with a hot plate and a view of Union Square.

Some of these blogs have also, however, gone on romantically and at length about aspects of living in the neighborhood about which they clearly need to remove their rose colored glasses, namely, the ludicrous idea that living in East Harlem, as it is right now (ie: pre-full gentrification) somehow gives the person in question "street cred". To which I just have to take a deep breath and say:

This "street cred" you speak of exists because the neighborhood still has lots of problems, problems in the areas of safety and quality of life. Taking pleasure or pride in street cred garnered by you choosing to live in a place where others don't have choice, others who aren't making the decision to live in East Harlem because it is a good value, but rather because they simply can't afford to go elsewhere is, in a word, revolting. Which makes you, in several more words, an insensitive, spoiled asshole.

Sigh.

Where am I going with this?

This is where I am going.

The other night we had some friends over to watch a soccer game and grill up some hot dogs. We were able to have a fair amount of people up, because living in East Harlem allows us to have a much bigger space than we would be able to afford elsewhere. We were able to grill because this same choice allows us to have outdoor space. FULL DISCLOSURE: I live in East Harlem because I get more for my money! Not to cash in on street cred! Because that would be as stupid as it sounds!

As the festivities proceeded I heard from the folks sitting in the aforementioned outside space that kids from a neighboring public park were throwing stones into our garden. Much discussion of "kids being kids" ensued, including some talk about what we had all done as kids, which was a fair amount of not much. Turns out most of our parents had us in as soon as it got dark.

But then the stones kept coming, and some of them came fast, and these little fuckers started getting bigger. Boulder size? Certainly not, but big enough that if they had hit a glass, or a window, or an eyeball, there is no doubt there would have been damage. And then at some point, I don't know, there was another stone and I, to put it mildly, lost my shit. I don't know if it was some sort of pregnancy rage but I had visions of my baby playing in that garden and getting hit by a stone, or one of our friends getting clocked in the eye for the audacity of spending the day with us. Before I knew what was happening I was standing outside a public park yelling at a group of little kids.

The kids were unsupervised (of course they were. Why don't we put that under the handy title of "street cred" too: a neighborhood abounding with children who are getting no attention or guidance! How cooooool is that Mr. Street Cred!?) and here we were yelling at them, like crazy, out-of-control morons. And, as you can probably imagine, it didn't stop the rocks anyway. Eventually, at our landlord's insistence, we called the cops.

We called the cops on little kids.

So, like, to review: we had to call the police on small children.

The whole experience left me feeling...drained. And sad. And confused about what I should have done. Retreat inside? Throw the rocks back? Try to reason with them instead of yell? Even now, I'm still confused and angry about it; regretting my actions but still wondering, what was the right thing to do? What would have made the situation better? Why can't I shake this feeling that now this is just going to happen, all summer, turning our little garden into a place of frustration that we avoid instead of enjoy.

And, honestly, kids throwing rocks is really the least of our problems. I'm telling this story more to elaborate on this whole tale of my living situation. Filling out the corners, so to speak.

When I first moved to East Harlem 8 years ago I was aware of very little. I was so focused on adjusting to city life I didn't notice most of the things that were obvious to everyone else. "Isn't it dangerous?" people would ask. "Don't you feel nervous going home alone at night?" And, you know what? I never did. My neighborhood lacks in some amenities, sure, but all the basics are there, all the things that make living in NYC great. I have built relationships with so many people around my home. I always wave at the pizza guys and they always wave back. The women at my supermarket ask about my family and grin at my pregnant belly as if they were my family too. Ali at the deli scolds me when I go out in cool weather with my hair wet and comes out from behind the counter to shake my hand and ask how I am. Tika at the bakery knows we like the ciabatta best. My neighbors and I, both former and current, have developed strong bonds, caring for each other's children, pets and plants. Sharing meals and holidays. And yet.

Not a month ago some kids went up and down 118th street and smashed in almost every windshield. A week later someone burned out a BMW, leaving an acrid smell and a charred mess on the cars unfortunate enough to be parked in front and behind. There are gunshots, usually in the summer and far enough from us that we've become somewhat used to it, but still, gunshots! Litter is getting bad again, like it was when I first moved here which may not seem important but points, I think to a general trend of ambivalence and disuse. The times when I get yelled at, called a cracker and worse, are moving towards each other in frequency, not apart.

So, I wonder about these other people, these people so enamored with the neighborhood they've lived in for 1 or 2 or 3 years. Are they just not seeing things for what they really are? Am I just unlucky, constantly in the wrong place at the wrong time? How is it that the existence of Costco seems to make these bozos feel better? Or the plans to build the East Harlem cultural center, something that has been promised for nearly a decade? How are these same people who seem beguiled by grit comforted through clinging to these false harbingers of an idyllic East Harlem just over the horizon? Because I'm scared about the direction things are moving, and street cred doesn't make me feel better.

Frankly, that is the kind of credit I can live without.

Photobucket

14 comments:

Dan Mac said...

Street cred is something you want to have, but not something you want to earn. But I think it's important to define what one means by "street cred." If it's just an attitude that some young poseur wants to lord over his downtown friends, he's an idiot. My impression has always been that street cred makes you safer. Simply put, when you're in a questionable neighborhood, if you can move with confidence and without observable fear, you're less likely to get fucked with. In that regard street cred has value, but I get the sense that that's not what your bloggers mean when they use the term; in that context it sounds like another variety of the New Yorker's hipper-than-thou raison d'etre. Which is stupid. And honestly, counter-productive. Anyone walking the street with that kind of attitude is probably just as likely to invite trouble as a suburban yokel.

Margie said...

Hmm, I'm thinking about this one long and hard. I'm sad that it's come to that; calling the cops on kids but you really didn't have much options. I would have done the same and I have.

My parents still live in my childhood home and what upsets me is the gentrification. The property value has risen, about double or triple from some years ago thus raising property taxes. That alone has driven out the people that have lived there for decades. It's sad and yet people don't see what they are doing to the neighborhood. They have rose-colored glasses on as well and it makes me sad. The Old Man will be hitting retirement age in 2 years and he will not have to pay anymore property taxes. (Sigh of relief.)

What worries me is that Teeny is coming soon and you will be a parent and oy.

SaintTigerlily said...

I totally agree and, in this case, I think it is the secondary and far douchier reason, which is why it bothers me so much. I find it particularly offensive because of the fact, as I stated, that there are more than likely many people who would love to move away from East Harlem but are unable to. So to take pleasure in the gritty nature of the neighborhood, like it is some Disney effect, is asshattery at its most irritating and I could never ever get behind it. I will say it now and will stand behind this statement: If I could get my apartment elsewhere in the city for the same price or even, to be honest, several hundred dollars more, I would be out of there so quick I would leave one of those dust puffs like the Road Runner. I am not ashamed of that.

SaintTigerlily said...

Margie - I'm sorry to hear that. This is the other side of gentrification, which, I think, is just a complicated issue for everyone involved. I'm glad your dad will soon be in the safe zone and I hope that your parents will continue to be able to live in the neighborhood that they love. Ousting people, particularly people who have lived in their neighborhoods for a long time is never ok.

Margie said...

I'm all for improving the neighborhood, etc. but this is one of the side effects of not passing zoning laws. How a city as big as Houston not have zoning laws is beyond me. My parents now have a popular cafe/bar across about 3 houses over and across the street with live music on Friday nights. Parking is terrible and I'm just trying to clock in some time with my parents.

Street cred = dumb.

Liam O'Malley said...

Ugh, what a shitty way for your day to go. I'm sorry to hear about it. I think you probably did the right thing but it's tough in that sort of situation because none of the options feels like the right thing. I just hope it won't become a recurring issue with those kids now.

Kristin @ Going Country said...

Well, THAT'S a way to ruin a party. Little punks.

I used to live in a neighborhood in Phoenix that sounds something like yours. Routine gunshots and flyovers by the police helicopter, neighbors in my apartment complex whacking each other with beer bottles, syringes in the parking lot. And oddly, I was never afraid. I think I was too young and naive to be scared. Also, like you, it was what I could afford at the time. Without having to drive an hour to get to work, that is.

famdoz said...

We lived in a similar neighbourhood and, like you, it was kind of OK when it was us as a couple. Then we started getting sick of the inconveniences: baby with 40°C temp and the 24hr medical service wont come to the suburb because they've been held up and physically hurt so many times, the dealers that come out after sundown, the local clothes designer who had the gumption to open her own store and then closed it because she'd been held up too many times for it to be profitable... but nothing bad ever happened to us there, and we met some very dear people.

The population is diversifying (which is good for everyone) but we made the decision to move. Was it abandoning ship? Yeah, and we felt and still feel guilty about it but at the end of the day, would we have been doing Milan a favour sending him to the local primary school that is so bad even the teachers talk it down, just for the sake of our principles? Nope.

You will look at things differently once Teeny comes along and make well-informed decisions from there.

Are we talking Inter Milan v Munich? Was Rob a happy boy?

dragonflies on lamp posts said...

You know its funny, after high school a friend and I would head out to Spanish Harlem to hang out with some friends.

We were always asked the same thing, how could we go there and not be afraid, and of course my favorite, don't you know you are white?!

I have always thought that if you can head there without fear you have a less likelyhood of getting screwed with.

The hubby and I lived in the "ghetto" on Long Island for awhile, we heard the gunshots and had people beaten and robbed in our own front yard. It sucks plain and simple but I hate the stigma that some of these places get.

And then you have the children even in my neighborhood now, they run around without any concern...and what boggles my mind if that the parents let them. It really makes me wonder how children are raised these days.

I know if there is one thing that I am good at, its being a mother. My children are raised to be respectful and honest. They know to listen to adults and behave accordingly...and they are still funny, wonderful little boys.

But maybe I am biased.

emma discovery said...

This is really thought-provoking. I hope you never staple these pages together.

So I tried to think of how I might have handled it, and my gut reaction, I think, would have been to throw the rocks back - NOT a good solution, and I can't imagine myself actually following through. I do think, sadly, that calling the cops was your only real option.

SaintTigerlily said...

First of all, thanks to everyone for your thoughtful dialogue on this - I think it is a sticky subject and it speaks well of everyone in this comments section that we are able to talke about it respectfully.

Second, thanks for not judging me too harshly - you guys are the best.

I'd like to address a few things directly.

famdoz: I TOTALLY understand that feeling like you abandoned your neighborhood, just as I equally and totally understand, even with him still locked up safely in my womb, how I would never sacrifice Teeny's safety for the sake of my principles. I even had to take a second and think about it when Rob moved in with me, mostly because I think he forms something of a larger target than I ever did.

Dragonflies - Sadly I think a lot of these neighborhoods get saddled with stigmas for good reason. East Harlem is amazing in so many ways and oddly, SUCH a family neighborhood I think, more than anything else. There are just some bad elements that spoil it for everyone else - and I do not think they have even a slight majority as far as neighborhood make-up. Sadly it only takes one smashed up car to really freak a person out. Let's also clarify here that I am not freaked out in the slightest. I've been on my street for 8 years. I'm just saddened, because I think the neighborhood and the people in the neighborhood can do better and deserve better.

Vivian said...

Please don't hit the delete button on your posts! Really. You're not annoying. In fact, your angry posts are refreshing because they're honest.

I also would have felt horrible calling the cops, but I would have done the same thing. Those kids needed to learn that there are consequences for their actions, and there wasn't really any other effective alternative.

Anonymous said...

Please, take this as simply a question, not a judgment of any sort. At all. My kid(s) are grown and gone. Safe and sound in their own realities. My exposure to gun shots and crazies and un-supervised children were small compared to the happenings in "big, bad New York City". So I ask this gently and quietly, "What can you contribute to change the "flavor" of your neighborhood?" Not gentrifying it, but connecting to it. Of course, it sounds like you're already doing that by connecting to the people that live there. But maybe there are deeper connections to make. Or not. It’s not your job to change the planet. Again, this is not a judgment. I'm an admirerer of your site, your writing and your honesty in both. And without 3 glasses of wine probably wouldn't have dared to leave a comment.
Brenda
PS - I love quotation marks too. Please keep up the great sharing.

SaintTigerlily said...

Vivian - Thanks for the encouragement. Consider this one Wilbured. (Obtuse Charlotte's Web reference that only I will understand?)

Brenda - Not taken as a judgement at all, and you make an excellent point. As you say, I have taken some steps, I try to connect to the people in my neighborhood who seem willing to make connections (most do not, this is NYC after all.) I have thought about taking an extra step, perhaps volunteering for an after school tutoring program or at the assisted living home just down the block, and maybe this is the time I need to take whatever anger I have and make it into something productive. Thank you for reminding me of that. And, may I suggest ALWAYS having 3 glasses of wine before commenting - that was a beautifully put and candid point.